Second chance romance books

Start with Unforgivable, Ella Miles’s contemporary romance series with the “Second chances” cue. Its clearest ex-lovers reunion is Heart of a Liar, book 2 in the listed order: the heroine broke up with Luca almost two years ago, and now he has walked into her veterinarian clinic. Browse Heart of a Thief, Heart of a Liar, and Heart of a Prick in that order, or explore Unforgivable: The Complete Series.

Last updated:

These contemporary romance books are for adult readers. The descriptions contain explicit language and sexual content; check each book’s description before choosing.

What does second chance romance mean for readers?

Second chance romance begins with history: two people have already mattered to each other, and a new encounter asks whether there is still a relationship worth pursuing. For readers looking for exes to lovers romance books, the appeal can be very specific. You want the attraction to come with remembered intimacy, an old hurt, and a reason that starting again is difficult. A familiar face returning is only the beginning; the circumstances of the earlier separation shape what that return means.

It helps to separate a reunion between former lovers from other stories about the past. A returning spouse can create a choice between relationships. An ex’s proposal can arrive alongside an entirely new attraction. A series can carry a second-chances theme without every book description showing an ex-couple getting back together. This guide makes those distinctions so you can choose the premise you actually want, then open the full description before deciding on a book.

Where does Ella Miles’s catalog fit?

Unforgivable is the Ella Miles series to explore for the “Second chances” cue, alongside “Dark pasts.” Its genre is Contemporary romance. Those series cues give you a starting point, but the individual descriptions tell you more about each relationship. Heart of a Liar supplies the clearest former-lovers setup: Luca’s lies caused a breakup, almost two years have passed, and seeing him again brings back a desire the heroine had hoped to leave behind.

Her plan is to have him “one last time” and then send him away. That puts the tension between her intentions and her attraction at the center of the premise. She remembers both what went wrong and how well Luca knows her. The description also asks whether his lies conceal a secret she was never supposed to know. It offers a reason to question the past without settling what that secret is, whether she will forgive him, or how the relationship ends.

What is each Unforgivable book about?

Heart of a Thief introduces Asher, a self-described villain who steals happily-ever-afters. His description presents a man trying to put a horrible life behind him through surfing and stealing, with a history of pursuing women and leaving heartbreak behind. Sloane runs a charity helping children who need a fresh start, and Asher wants her even though she is about to marry another man. That is the stated obstacle in this opening book; its description is not an ex-reunion story.

Heart of a Liar is second in the listed order. The heroine says she broke up with Luca almost two years earlier because he lied. When he enters her veterinarian clinic, her emotional and physical response clashes with her determination to stay away. If you came here specifically for a former couple confronting their attraction again, this is the description to inspect most closely. The clinic encounter, the elapsed time, and the unresolved lies make its reunion premise clear.

Heart of a Prick is third. Its heroine is spending a week at a resort and wants a man who can match her sexual desires. Beneath the drinks and beach setting, she needs a distraction from trouble waiting at home, and she is not sure how to stay alive. This description is not an ex-reunion story either. The “Second chances” label applies to Unforgivable as a series; it does not turn Asher’s pursuit or the resort week into a reunion that their descriptions never promise.

Other Ella Miles books with a past that comes back

These are adjacent reading options, not second chance romance recommendations. Aligned: Volume 3 brings back Alex’s husband, whom she thought was dead, while she loves Landon. His return creates a love triangle and a returning-husband dilemma: Alex’s heart is divided, and Landon believes he must let her go. That differs from a straightforward reunion between two exes. The reveal belongs to the third volume of the four-volume Aligned series; begin with Aligned: Volume 1 to follow Alex and Landon’s story.

Definitely Yes introduces Scarlett Bell ten years after a dark past that threatened her best friend. She now has a fashion and beauty empire, a New York apartment, and a desire for love, marriage, and a baby. A question from an ex-lover and a text from a dangerous stranger present two choices. The description centers on choosing between those men; later books follow Scarlett and Beast. It is not a classic exes-reunite story, so choose it for that competing-choice premise rather than assuming the ex is the relationship the series will follow.

How do I choose a second chance story?

Start with the kind of shared past you want to revisit. Heart of a Liar gives you an adult breakup, a gap of almost two years, and renewed attraction complicated by lies. Every Summer After offers Percy and Sam’s six summers together and a return a decade later for his mother’s funeral. Before We Were Strangers begins its search for reunion after fifteen years out of touch, when Matt glimpses Grace on a New York subway platform. The length of the separation and the reason for meeting again give each premise a different focus.

Next, consider how the present-day encounter unfolds. Happy Place keeps Harriet and Wyn together at a Maine cottage while their friends still think they are a couple. Before We Were Strangers makes finding the other person the immediate problem, through a missed-connection ad. Heart of a Liar puts the former lover directly in front of the heroine at her workplace. Choose the situation that interests you: sustaining a pretense, trying to reconnect, or deciding what to do when the person you left returns.

Finally, distinguish the shape of the book from the shape of the relationship. The three other-author picks below are standalone novels. Unforgivable has three titles in its listed order and a complete-series edition, with reading options on its series page. Aligned is a four-volume story to begin at Volume 1. A reunion premise alone does not tell you how a book fits within a series, and this guide does not assign individual ending or standalone claims to the Unforgivable books.

Is this the right guide if I want dark romance?

This is a contemporary romance guide. Unforgivable’s “Dark pasts” cue describes part of its appeal, but its listed genre is Contemporary romance. A book can include explicit sex, lies, or danger without that changing its catalog genre. Heart of a Prick’s concern about trouble back home and Heart of a Liar’s hidden-secret question are reasons to read the descriptions carefully, not reasons to relabel the series.

If your next read needs to come from Ella’s dark romance catalog, the dark romance hub and dark contemporary romance guide offer those starting points. If your priority is a former lover returning, stay with Heart of a Liar’s premise and compare the other-author picks below. These are different ways to choose your next book, and neither a genre label nor a reunion setup supplies a heat rating or a promise about an ending.

Heart of a Thief book cover

Unforgivable reading order

The listed Unforgivable order is Heart of a Thief, Heart of a Liar, then Heart of a Prick. Heart of a Liar has the explicit ex-lovers reunion. The series cues are Dark pasts and Second chances; they do not describe every individual book as an ex-reunion story.

Three listed novels plus Unforgivable: The Complete Series. Visit the series page for reading options.

Full descriptions and retailer options

3 numbered books, plus a collection

  1. Heart of a Thief
  2. Heart of a Liar
  3. Heart of a Prick
Unforgivable: books in reading order
BookTitleMain tropes and story themesStandalone or cliffhangerBuy links
1Heart of a ThiefStory themes not specifiedSee the series page for reading optionsAmazon
2Heart of a LiarStory themes not specifiedSee the series page for reading optionsAmazon
3Heart of a PrickStory themes not specifiedSee the series page for reading optionsAmazon
CollectionUnforgivable: The Complete SeriesStory themes not specifiedSee the series page for reading optionsAmazon

Unforgivable: The Complete Series is the collection edition, listed separately from the three numbered novels. Use its Amazon link above to view that edition, or visit the series page for the individual descriptions and supported reading links.

More second chance romance picks from other authors

Ella Miles is the author of this site; the other picks are by other authors. Amazon links are affiliate links.

  • Every Summer After

    By Carley Fortune. Standalone novel (2022).

    From the publisher/author description: Percy and Sam spent six summers together at a lake in Barry's Bay before it fell apart. A decade later she returns for his mother's funeral. Told across six past summers and one present-day weekend.

    Pick for: Childhood friends, a summer town, and a decade apart.

    View Every Summer After on Amazon
  • Happy Place

    By Emily Henry. Standalone novel (2023).

    From the publisher/author description: Harriet and Wyn broke up five months ago but haven't told their friends, so they pretend to still be a couple for the group's last week at a Maine cottage.

    Pick for: Exes forced to fake it for a week.

    View Happy Place on Amazon
  • Before We Were Strangers

    By Renée Carlino. Standalone novel (2015).

    From the publisher/author description: Fifteen years after they lost touch, Matt glimpses Grace on a New York subway platform and posts a missed-connection ad to find her.

    Pick for: College loves reunited fifteen years later.

    View Before We Were Strangers on Amazon

Questions readers ask

Which Ella Miles book should I explore for second chance romance?

Heart of a Liar is the clearest ex-lovers reunion in Unforgivable, the series listed with the Second chances cue. It is book 2 in the listed order. The heroine broke up with Luca almost two years earlier because he lied; his visit to her veterinarian clinic brings their attraction back into focus.

What is the Unforgivable reading order?

The listed order is Heart of a Thief, Heart of a Liar, then Heart of a Prick. The series page provides the full descriptions and reading options. Heart of a Thief and Heart of a Prick do not describe ex-reunion stories; the Second chances cue applies to the series.

Is there a complete Unforgivable edition?

Yes. Unforgivable: The Complete Series is listed as a collection alongside the three novels. Its Amazon edition is B07G6TH767. The reading-order table includes a separate collection link so you can distinguish it from each individual book.

Is Unforgivable dark romance?

No. Unforgivable is listed as Contemporary romance, with Dark pasts and Second chances as series cues. For Ella’s dark romance catalog, follow the dark romance books hub or the dark contemporary romance books guide linked above.

Are these books for adults?

Yes. This guide is for adult readers. The Unforgivable descriptions contain explicit language and sexual content, including the heroine’s stated desires in Heart of a Prick. Check each book’s full description before choosing; this guide does not assign a heat rating.

What should I read next?

For another exes-reunion premise, compare Every Summer After, Happy Place, and Before We Were Strangers. For an adjacent Ella Miles story, Aligned includes a returning-husband dilemma in Volume 3; begin with Volume 1. Definitely Yes presents a choice involving an ex and a dangerous stranger, rather than a classic exes reunion.

Your next obsession
could start with a free book.

Join Ella’s email reader club for a free book, news, and reader offers.

Join the reader club